Can two serial cheaters get a second chance at love? After a one-night stand in college, New Yorkers Lainey and Jake meet by chance twelve years later and discover they each have the same problem: because of their monogamy-challenged ways, neither can maintain a relationship. Determined to stay friends despite their mutual attraction, they make a pact to keep it platonic, a deal that proves easier said than done.
Jason Sudeikis
as Jake Harper
Alison Brie
as Lainey Dalton
Adam Scott
as Matthew Sobvechik
Jason Mantzoukas
as Xander
Natasha Lyonne
as Kara
Adam Brody
as Sam
Amanda Peet
as Paula
Katherine Waterston
as Emma
Marc Blucas
as Chris Smith
Margarita Levieva
as Hannah
Andrea Savage
as Naomi
Daniella Pineda
as Danica
